{"schema_version":"3.0","source":"SCORECARD_METHODOLOGY.md v2.0, canonicalized 2026-07-21. Weight set matches the 70 shipped records (contentforge lineage). The doc's trailing Red Flags Checklist is merged into the dimension tables below; where the two conflicted, the structured dimension table won.","weights":{"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY":0.3,"PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY":0.25,"TECHNICAL_FEASIBILITY":0.2,"SUPPLY_CHAIN_RISK":0.15,"COMMUNICATION_QUALITY":0.1},"baselines":{"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY":50,"PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY":50,"TECHNICAL_FEASIBILITY":70,"SUPPLY_CHAIN_RISK":60,"COMMUNICATION_QUALITY":70},"dimension_names":{"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY":"Creator Credibility","PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY":"Product Authenticity","TECHNICAL_FEASIBILITY":"Technical Feasibility","SUPPLY_CHAIN_RISK":"Supply Chain Risk","COMMUNICATION_QUALITY":"Communication Quality"},"kill_switches":[{"id":"kill.arbitrage","label":"Reselling/Arbitrage: product listed on AliExpress/Alibaba/Temu dated prior to campaign launch","required_methods":["reverse_image","marketplace_search"]},{"id":"kill.identity_fraud","label":"Identity fraud: creator photo is stock or AI-generated","required_methods":["reverse_image","human_judgment"]},{"id":"kill.bad_actor","label":"Creator linked to banned account or known scam ring","required_methods":["search","human_judgment"]},{"id":"kill.impossible_physics","label":"Claims violate basic physics","required_methods":["human_judgment"]}],"kill_switch_cap":20,"rules":[{"id":"creator.zero_zero","dimension":"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY","points":-20,"label":"Zero-Zero profile (0 created, 0 backed)","methods":["platform_data"]},{"id":"creator.rugpull","dimension":"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY","points":-50,"label":"Previous campaign failed to deliver (rugpull)","methods":["platform_data","search"]},{"id":"creator.late_delivery","dimension":"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY","points":-30,"label":"Previous campaign delivered >1 year late with poor communication","methods":["platform_data","search"]},{"id":"creator.failed_unaddressed","dimension":"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY","points":-25,"label":"Previous failed/canceled campaign not addressed in current campaign","methods":["platform_data","search"]},{"id":"creator.no_external_verification","dimension":"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY","points":-10,"label":"No external social verification (LinkedIn/website/company registration)","methods":["search"]},{"id":"creator.delivered_before","dimension":"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY","points":30,"label":"Successfully delivered 1+ campaigns to satisfied backers","methods":["platform_data","search"]},{"id":"creator.community_backer","dimension":"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY","points":10,"label":"Backer history > 5 projects (part of the community)","methods":["platform_data"]},{"id":"creator.verified_identity","dimension":"CREATOR_CREDIBILITY","points":10,"label":"Verified real identity (established professional/company history)","methods":["search","human_judgment"]},{"id":"authenticity.renders_only","dimension":"PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY","points":-40,"label":"Only 3D renders shown, no photos of a physical unit","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"authenticity.prototype_mismatch","dimension":"PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY","points":-20,"label":"Prototype looks materially different from renders","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"authenticity.cgi_demo","dimension":"PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY","points":-20,"label":"Demo video fully CGI or heavily edited with no raw footage","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"authenticity.whitelabel_suspected","dimension":"PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY","points":-50,"label":"Resale/rebrand of an existing product (short of verified pre-launch listing, which is a kill switch)","methods":["reverse_image","marketplace_search"]},{"id":"authenticity.raw_demo","dimension":"PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY","points":30,"label":"Raw, uncut video demo of prototype functioning as claimed","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"authenticity.third_party_review","dimension":"PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY","points":10,"label":"Independent third-party hands-on review exists","methods":["search"]},{"id":"authenticity.factory_photos","dimension":"PRODUCT_AUTHENTICITY","points":10,"label":"Factory/tooling photos showing production preparation","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"technical.too_good","dimension":"TECHNICAL_FEASIBILITY","points":-30,"label":"Too-good-to-be-true specs vs comparable products","methods":["human_judgment","search"]},{"id":"technical.undercapitalized","dimension":"TECHNICAL_FEASIBILITY","points":-20,"label":"Funding goal under ~50% of estimated BOM/tooling cost","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"technical.timeline_aggressive","dimension":"TECHNICAL_FEASIBILITY","points":-10,"label":"Aggressive timeline (<3 months from campaign end to hardware delivery)","methods":["platform_data"]},{"id":"technical.challenges_explained","dimension":"TECHNICAL_FEASIBILITY","points":20,"label":"Clean explanation of specific technical challenges and solutions","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"technical.off_the_shelf","dimension":"TECHNICAL_FEASIBILITY","points":10,"label":"Standard/off-the-shelf components lower execution risk","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"supply.no_mfg_partner","dimension":"SUPPLY_CHAIN_RISK","points":-20,"label":"No manufacturing partner named","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"supply.shipping_undefined","dimension":"SUPPLY_CHAIN_RISK","points":-20,"label":"Shipping rates undefined or charged later with no estimates","methods":["platform_data","human_judgment"]},{"id":"supply.sku_complexity","dimension":"SUPPLY_CHAIN_RISK","points":-10,"label":"Complex customization options create SKU-count risk","methods":["platform_data"]},{"id":"supply.flexible_funding_no_roadmap","dimension":"SUPPLY_CHAIN_RISK","points":-15,"label":"Flexible funding with no production roadmap","methods":["platform_data","human_judgment"]},{"id":"supply.verified_logistics","dimension":"SUPPLY_CHAIN_RISK","points":20,"label":"Named logistics/fulfillment partner","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"supply.tooling_photos","dimension":"SUPPLY_CHAIN_RISK","points":20,"label":"Photos of molds/tooling creation","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"comms.silent_creator","dimension":"COMMUNICATION_QUALITY","points":-30,"label":"Creator silent in comments (0 replies to backer questions)","methods":["comments_review"]},{"id":"comms.word_salad","dimension":"COMMUNICATION_QUALITY","points":-20,"label":"Word-salad updates: vague philosophy, no concrete progress","methods":["human_judgment"]},{"id":"comms.deleting_comments","dimension":"COMMUNICATION_QUALITY","points":-10,"label":"Deleting negative comments","methods":["comments_review"]},{"id":"comms.detailed_faq","dimension":"COMMUNICATION_QUALITY","points":10,"label":"Detailed FAQ covering refunds and warranty","methods":["platform_data"]},{"id":"comms.active_technical","dimension":"COMMUNICATION_QUALITY","points":10,"label":"Active creator participation with technical depth","methods":["comments_review"]}],"rating_bands":[{"min":80,"rating":"Low Risk","label":"Low risk profile - proceed with standard diligence"},{"min":60,"rating":"Medium-Low","label":"Moderate risk - due diligence recommended"},{"min":40,"rating":"Medium","label":"Elevated risk - exercise caution"},{"min":21,"rating":"Medium-High","label":"High risk - significant concerns"},{"min":0,"rating":"High Risk","label":"Critical risk - avoid"}],"affiliate_threshold":60,"valid_methods":["platform_data","search","reverse_image","marketplace_search","comments_review","human_judgment"]}